He was trained to be part of the decor, another piece of furniture, as it were. The butlers danny strong on tackling ronald reagan vulture. The butler full title lee daniels the butler is a 20 american historical drama film directed and coproduced by lee daniels and with a screenplay by danny strong. The butler presents an historically inaccurate portrait of ronald. All we can do as moviegoers is judge a film by the effectiveness of its message, and on this front, the butler succeeds with enough heart, humor and history to overcome its timelapse pace. Rounding out this allstar cast is robin williams as dwight eisenhower, john cusack as richard nixon, alan rickman as ronald reagan, james marsden as john f. Today, danny strong discusses the challenge of incorporating ronald reagan into lee daniels the butler, which is winding down its fatherson story of gracious white house butler cecil forest. Join facebook to connect with reagan butler and others you may know. Williams plays against type as eisenhower, the celebrated warriorstatesman who supervised the dday invasion and presided over a decade of. The butler presents an historically inaccurate portrait. Its clear that eugene allen, the man on whom the butlers cecil gaines forest whitaker is based, was. Peter receive the house his dead mother left for him in her will. Aug 19, 20 two biographers of ronald reagan have taken issue with lee daniels film the butler, claiming it presents a misleading impression of the former presidents views on race relations. When we first started getting messages at the facebook page of reagan.
The butler, based on the story of longtime white house butler eugene allen, hits theaters friday. Reagan republicans freak out over the butler and race. When fonda first enters the frame as nancy reagan, listen very. The butler 20 cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more.
The butler marches through civil rights history wtop. Aug 27, 20 reagan said the movie, which supposedly is based on the life of eugene allen, who worked as a butler in the white house for 34 years, is filled with inaccuracies for the purpose of disparaging his fathers name. The butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says son. Oprah winfrey plays his wife, gloria, while alan rickman is. As cecil gaines serves eight presidents during his tenure as a butler at the white house, the civil rights movement, vietnam, and other major events affect this mans life, family, and american society.
Williams plays against type as eisenhower, the celebrated warriorstatesman who supervised the d. With luis borge, fernando vinocour, abelardo vladich, adriana viquez. The butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says. Aug 07, 20 lee daniels the butler 810 movie clip the importance of the black butler 20 hd duration. Reagan plays it straight to neals high strung bridetobe, which gives the rest of the cast the chance to shine in broader, comedic parts. What looks like passive obliviousness is just a black man playing one of the only roles that granted him upward mobility in the 20th century, the unquestioning servant. The butler presents an historically inaccurate portrait of.
President reagans son attacks lee daniels the butler. Lee daniels the butler tells the story of a white house butler who served eight american presidents over three decades. Many historians have heavily criticised the portrayal of. The butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says son film. Aug 29, 20 the butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says son this article is more than 6 years old michael reagan accuses lee daniels film about african american white house butler of harbouring. The butler is much more of rich experience than you would imagine, aided by stellar performances by its varied cast including forest whitaker, oprah winfrey, jane fonda, liev schrieber, lenny kravitz, robin williams, cuba gooding, jr. Mar 27, 2016 the movie begins with cecil gaines working on a plantation in 1926 with his father and mother. Reagan said the movie, which supposedly is based on the life of eugene allen, who worked as a butler in the white house for 34 years, is filled with inaccuracies for the purpose of disparaging his fathers name. Jane fonda tells veterans boycotting her movie the butler. It was really challenging, because it was the end of the movie and i. Prominent historians of ronald reagan say the portrayal of the former presidents views on race in the butler perpetuates stereotypes and inaccuracies that.
Have you heard about the rightwing outrage over the butler, the movie about the faithful white house retainer who served under presidents from dwight d. Parents need to know that lee daniels the butler is a sweeping look at the history of africanamerican life in the united states, as witnessed by a black butler forest whitaker who spent three decades working in the white house. Eugene allen, the actual white house butler on whom the film is supposedly based, kept signed photos of ronald and nancy reagan in his living room pictures of the other presidents he had served. The butler is a 20 american historical drama film directed and coproduced by lee daniels. How much of the butler is fact and how much is fiction. The true story behind the butler movie reveals that the situation was much more complex than lee daniels film makes it appear. The butler movie depicts president ronald reagan alan rickman stating that he will refuse to impose sanctions against south africa for its racist policies. When the butler comes out on august 16, there will be three black men that made it happen director lee daniels, white house butler eugene allen and journalist wil haygood, who wrote the original washington post article, a butler well served by this election that inspired the movie. Any movie that casts jane fonda as nancy reagan certainly has a piquant sense of humor, but the prankishness of lee daniels the butler. Two biographers of ronald reagan have taken issue with lee daniels film the butler, claiming it presents a misleading impression of the former presidents views. Lee daniels, who gained fame as a director with the 2009 film precious, surely imagined great cinematic potential when he signed on to bring to the big screen the story of eugene allen, a reallife white house butler who served u. His mother is raped by the white plantation owner and the father is shot dead immediately following. The story is told in a chronological order, so that the viewer gets to see the world changing, particularly for african americans through the eyes of this butler.
Aug 27, 20 the film, scripted by danny strong game change, is inspired by the life of real white house butler eugene allen, who worked at the white house from 1952 to 1986 and whom the younger reagan knew. Peter realizes that maybe the butler and his daughter have a hidden agenda. It is inspired by wil haygoods washington post article a butler well served by this election. The actors in this movie were fantastic, however the rewriting of history was terrible. The butler is a nice idea for a movie, but has a mostly silly script and some of the craziest and most laughable casting imaginable. President reagans son slams lee daniels the butler e. Aug 16, 20 in the movie, though, the butlers name is cecil gaines, played by forrest whitaker. The butler quit because he was upset with president reagans support of apartheid in south africa. The butler director lee daniels, harvey weinstein defend. The real story behind the butler black america web. Oprah winfrey plays his wife, gloria, while alan rickman is ronald reagan and jane fonda is nancy reagan.
Jan 24, 2014 after harry potter had finally finished filming, alan rickman wrote a letter thats deeply moving duration. Peter is visited by his mothers butler and his daughter. When jane fonda was cast as former first lady nancy reagan in lee daniels forthcoming film the butler, some reagan fans were not pleased. Historians dispute portrayal of ronald reagan in the butler. Cecil is then trained to be a houseman, eventually running. Just say no to the critics of jane fonda playing nancy reagan in lee daniels the butler the new box office hit has come under fire from some.
At the time, america was entangled in the cold war with the. The butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says son michael reagan accuses lee daniels film about african american white house butler of harbouring a bunch of lies published. Cecil is then trained to be a houseman, eventually running away and learning how to become a butler. Aug 20, 20 just say no to the critics of jane fonda playing nancy reagan in lee daniels the butler the new box office hit has come under fire from some conservatives and war veterans because they dont. The movie begins with cecil gaines working on a plantation in 1926 with his father and mother. What the butler gets wrong about ronald reagan and race. The butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says son this article is more than 6 years old michael reagan accuses lee daniels film about african american white house butler of harbouring.
It is inspired by wil haygoods washington post article a butler well served by this election loosely based on the real life of eugene allen, who worked in the white house for decades, the film stars forest whitaker as cecil. Working from the true story of eugene allens rise from field hand to longstanding white house butler, daniels and screenwriter danny strong attempt to forrest gump africanamerican history. The film, scripted by danny strong game change, is inspired by the life of real white house butler eugene allen, who worked at the white house from 1952 to. In real life, helene allen was not an alcoholic, nor did she have an extramarital affair, according. Theres a particularly stirring moment in the butler when nancy reagan jane fonda, of all. It was very difficult to write because reagans record on civil rights was. Forest whitaker leads an allstar cast as a white house butler who served eight presidents while the civil rights movement and other major events affect his life, family, and society. The film traces the dramatic changes that swept american society during. Ronald reagan alan rickman barack obama orlando eric street butler moviepictures though the story spans a time that includes their. Heres a good way to determine whether youre seeing the butler in a red state or a blue state. For anyone skeptical of a movie about a black man who spent years in servitude, think again. There you go again, hollywood, michael reagan wrote on the website newsmax.
Since the movie chronicles the history of the civil rights movement, there are many scenes that portray hate crimes like two lynched men hanging from a tree. A top ronald reagan historian says the nations 40th president is not portrayed accurately in lee daniels the butler, the new hollywood film based on a reallife white house servant who worked under eight commandersinchief. Ronald reagan is portrayed by alan rickman in the butler. Arkansas 2020 movie official trailer vince vaughn, liam hemsworth, clark duke. When the butler hit theaters, the controversy sharpened as filmgoers saw a fictionalized account of ronald reagan and his relationship with the central character of the film, the white house. Aug 29, 20 what the butler gets wrong about ronald reagan and race. Ranking the presidents and first ladies in the butler. The movie shows the butlers son eventually rejecting the violent rhetoric of the black panther party.
Lee daniels the butler is a bunch of lies, says ronald reagans son, particularly in its portrayal of his father. At the same time, the allusions to postwar hardships that are taken in passing and would have been commonplace at the time really reflect conditions of the era in more realistic ways than equally. With forest whitaker, oprah winfrey, john cusack, jane fonda. Oprah winfrey plays gainess wife, gloria, with britains david oyelowo as his civil. Through seven administrations, cecil gaines worked as a butler in the white house, serving the most powerful men in the free world. In the movie, though, the butlers name is cecil gaines, played by forrest whitaker. Since the movie chronicles the history of the civil rights movement, there are many scenes that portray hate. The butler falsely portrays ronald reagan as racist, says son this article is more than 6 years old michael reagan accuses lee daniels film about african american white house butler of. Ronald reagan biographers attack his portrayal in the butler. However, at the end of the movie, the son leads a protest rally on the south african issue and accuses president reagan of trying to dismantle all civil rights protections for minorities. Lee daniels the butler 810 movie clip the importance of the black butler 20 hd duration.
Aug 15, 20 all we can do as moviegoers is judge a film by the effectiveness of its message, and on this front, the butler succeeds with enough heart, humor and history to overcome its timelapse pace. Aug 28, 20 when the butler hit theaters, the controversy sharpened as filmgoers saw a fictionalized account of ronald reagan and his relationship with the central character of the film, the white house. Aug 16, 20 a top ronald reagan historian says the nations 40th president is not portrayed accurately in lee daniels the butler, the new hollywood film based on a reallife white house servant who worked under eight commandersinchief. Michael reagan, son of former president ronald reagan, slammed the historical accuracy of the movie the butler, saying it inaccurately portrayed his father as racist. After harry potter had finally finished filming, alan rickman wrote a letter thats deeply moving duration. Paul kengor, one of president reagans biographers, also attacked the film, saying, ive talked to many white house staff, cooks, housekeepers. Aug 15, 20 any movie that casts jane fonda as nancy reagan certainly has a piquant sense of humor, but the prankishness of lee daniels the butler so named after a title dispute with the mpaa.
649 1499 364 1252 535 1240 247 1056 9 1315 1134 1284 350 896 868 248 533 1205 934 1254 545 595 802 1071 1059 918 1449 794 976 404 33 1361 1442